Sudden cardiac death in young athletes: Study suggests many ECG screenings are inaccurate
Incidents of young athletes collapsing during sports practice due to an undiagnosed heart condition are alarming, and have led some health care professionals to call for mandatory electrocardiogram (ECG) screenings before sport participation. Others, however, question the validity of such a mandate. A new study soon to be published in The Journal of Pediatrics examines the accuracy and effectiveness of pre-sport participation ECGs. Dr. Allison Hill and colleagues from Stanford University School of Medicine and Lucile Packard Children's Hospital and Pediatric Cardiology Associates conducted a survey to test the accuracy of ECG screenings. Fifty-three pediatric cardiologists were asked to interpret 18 ECGs, 8 from children with healthy hearts and 10 from children with heart conditions that could lead to sudden cardiac death. The accuracy of the cardiologists' interpretations was fairly low; the average score for overall accuracy was 67%. The cardiologists correctly restricted sport participation 81% of the time for children with heart conditions, and they correctly allowed participation 74% of the time for children with healthy hearts.
As Dr. Hill explains, "One problem with interpreting athletes' ECGs is that, as athletes' hearts grow stronger, they may get somewhat larger and beat more slowly. Although these changes are normal for a well-trained athlete, they can look similar on ECG scans to defects that predispose people to sudden cardiac death." As the test scores demonstrate, this similarity could lead to unnecessary exclusion of healthy young people from sport participation. And the reverse can also be true. According to Dr. Hill, "Some young athletes who are predisposed to sudden cardiac death may be given a clean bill of health based on a flawed ECG interpretation."
The researchers suggest that because ECGs are not always accurate and can be difficult to interpret, they may not be the perfect test for pre-screening athletes for heart conditions. "Although other countries have enacted laws mandating ECG screening for their athletes," Dr. Hill states, "the difficulty of interpreting ECG results, combined with the very large population of young athletes in the United States (over 10.7 million), may make such laws impractical." She and her colleagues suggest that, if young athletes are to be screened in this way, the physicians interpreting the ECG should be trained appropriately.
Source: Elsevier Health Sciences
- Researchers recommend preparticipation cardiac screening for college athletesThu, 26 May 2011, 9:33:16 EDT
- Adding ECG to health exams may prevent sudden cardiac death in young athletesMon, 1 Mar 2010, 17:49:08 EST
- Risks of delaying ACL reconstruction in young athletes may be too high, study showsSun, 12 Jul 2009, 0:42:23 EDT
- Sudden cardiac death affects about 1 in 44,000 NCAA athletes a yearMon, 4 Apr 2011, 16:39:50 EDT
- ECG testing of young athletes cost-effective in preventing deaths, Stanford study showsMon, 1 Mar 2010, 17:49:10 EST
Articles on the same topic
- Pediatric cardiologists not always accurate in interpreting ECG results for young athletesThu, 14 Jul 2011, 8:34:20 EDT
- Pediatric cardiologists not always accurate in interpreting ECG results for young athletesfrom PhysorgThu, 14 Jul 2011, 3:30:24 EDT
Latest Science NewsletterGet the latest and most popular science news articles of the week in your Inbox! It's free!
Learn more about
Check out our next project, Biology.Net
From other science news sites
Popular science news articles
- Which qubit my dear? New method to distinguish between neighbouring quantum bits
- New compound excels at killing persistent and drug-resistant tuberculosis
- How useful is fracking anyway? Study explores return of investment
- Chemical probe confirms that body makes its own rotten egg gas, H2S, to benefit health
- IQ link to baby's weight gain in first month
- Even with defects, graphene is strongest material in the world
- Detection of the cosmic gamma ray horizon: Measures all the light in the universe since the Big Bang
- Genetic engineering alters mosquitoes' sense of smell
- Allosaurus fed more like a falcon than a crocodile, new study finds
- 'Popcorn' particle pathways promise better lithium-ion batteries