Social scientists study impact of human adult stem cell research
New research says studying both adult and embryonic stem cells can benefit medical science, but banning the study of either type could harm studies of the other. Researchers from the University of Michigan, Stanford University and the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minn. recently investigated whether the increased number of studies with a certain type of adult stem cell has changed the overall course of research in the field.
The researchers analyzed more than 2,000 scientific papers and found adult stem cells are not replacing human embryonic stems cells in the laboratory. Instead, the two cell types have proven to be complementary and any disruption of federal funding, they say, would negatively impact stem cell research overall.
"This is an important study that systematically examines the co-authorship networks of stem cell research articles and uses those to understand the interactions between two complementary areas of research," says Julia Lane, program director for Science of Science & Innovation Policy at the National Science Foundation (NSF), which funded the study.
"It is particularly interesting because it uses new analytical techniques to advance our understanding of how the implementation of policy in one area can affect scientific research in another area."
The research appears in the June 9 journal Cell.
"The incentives to use both types of cell in comparative studies are high," says Jason Owen-Smith, a sociologist at University of Michigan. He notes the science behind adult stem cells that can be "reprogrammed," called human induced pluripotent stem cells (hiPSCs), is still in its infancy, having become widely available in 2007.
"As a result, induced pluripotent stem cells do not offer an easy solution to the difficult ethical questions surrounding embryonic stem cell research," he says.
Pluripotent stem cells are those capable of differentiating into any type of tissue, hence the attractiveness of embryonic stem cells, or hESCs, also called ES cells, which are also pluripotent.
The researchers examined stem cell research papers published between 1998 and 2010. They found the proportion of papers using human adult and human embryonic stem cells together is growing faster than those using adult stem cells alone.
In 2008, only 15 or 5.1 percent of all papers examined in the study reported using adult stem cells, and only three of those papers combined the use of human adult and human embryonic stem cells. By 2010, some 161 of 574 or 28 percent of papers reported on studies of both cell technologies, and 62.1 percent of those papers paired adult and embryonic cell lines.
Because use of the two cell types has become so intertwined, any federal policy that would deny funding for embryonic stem cell research "would derail work with a nascent and exciting technology," says Owen-Smith.
If federal funding stops for human embryonic stem cell research, it would have a serious negative impact on adult stem cell research, says Stanford University bioethicist Christopher Scott, one of the paper's co-authors. "We may never be able to choose between iPS and ES cell research because we don't know which type of cell will be best for eventual therapies."
"The whole point with science policy is to have a more scientific basis to understand the impacts of policy decisions on science if and when those decisions are made," says Lane
Source: National Science Foundation
- Induced pluripotent stem cells repair heart, Mayo Clinic study showsMon, 20 Jul 2009, 16:38:53 EDT
- Mayo's 'smart' adult stem cells repair heartsMon, 16 Aug 2010, 19:16:01 EDT
- Leukemia stem cells have more in common with embryonic stem cells than adult stem cellsThu, 5 Feb 2009, 12:45:38 EST
- Salk researchers reprogram adult stem cells in their natural environmentMon, 30 Jun 2008, 9:35:44 EDT
- U-M study reveals lack of diversity in embryonic stem cell linesWed, 16 Dec 2009, 17:24:33 EST
Articles on the same topic
- Curtailing embryonic stem cell research would also hurt iPS cell research, Stanford expert findsThu, 9 Jun 2011, 18:34:44 EDT
- Banning federal funding for human embryonic stem cell research would derail related workThu, 9 Jun 2011, 18:34:34 EDT
- Social scientists study impact of human adult stem cell researchfrom Science DailySat, 11 Jun 2011, 13:30:19 EDT
- Research on Induced Pluripotent and Embryonic Stem Cells 'Inextricably Intertwined'from Science NOWFri, 10 Jun 2011, 14:50:07 EDT
- Curtailing embryonic stem cell research would also hurt iPS cell research, analysis suggestsfrom Science DailyThu, 9 Jun 2011, 19:30:32 EDT
- Banning U.S. federal funding for human embryonic stem cell research would derail related work, experts arguefrom Science DailyThu, 9 Jun 2011, 18:30:25 EDT
- Banning federal funding for human embryonic stem cell research would derail related workfrom PhysorgThu, 9 Jun 2011, 13:30:38 EDT
Latest Science NewsletterGet the latest and most popular science news articles of the week in your Inbox! It's free!
Check out our next project, Biology.Net
From other science news sites
Popular science news articles
- UC Davis engineers create on-wetting fabric drains sweat
- Protein study suggests drug side effects are inevitable
- Amazon River exhales virtually all carbon taken up by rain forest
- Bed sharing leads to fivefold increase in risk of cot death for babies whose parents do not smoke
- Gym class reduces probability of obesity, study finds for first time
No popular news yet
No popular news yet
- Stem cell transplant restores memory, learning in mice
- 2 landmark studies report on success of using image-guided brachytherapy to treat cervical cancer
- Researchers discover mushrooms can provide as much vitamin D as supplements
- Cutting back on sleep harms blood vessel function and breathing control
- Study: Low-dose aspirin stymies proliferation of 2 breast cancer lines