Antibiotics: Longer treatment times that benefit children may cost society
The likelihood that the treatment of a middle ear infection will fail is slightly higher for a child who is given a shorter course of antibiotics, according to a new Cochrane Systematic Review. The results are conclusive, but the researchers say there are other factors that must be considered when the drugs are prescribed. Most children suffer at some point from a middle ear infection, also called acute otitis media (AOM). It is one of the most common reasons for children being prescribed antibiotics, at a cost of up to $5 billion each year in the US alone. Health practitioners vary in the length of course that they prescribe to treat the infection. The standard course in Britain is five days, whereas in North America it is ten. Due to concern about drug resistance caused by overuse, and the increasing cost of providing these drugs, the researchers decided to update a previous Cochrane Review carried out in 2000.
The updated review included 49 trials involving 12,045 children aged one month to 18 years, 22 of which were studies that had not been included in the original review. According to results, the likelihood of treatment failure with long course antibiotics was one in six compared to one in five with short course antibiotics. Long course was defined as more than one week, whereas short course was defined as less than one week. The researchers concluded that the policy of treating for five days might slightly increase the risk of a child experiencing further symptoms, or a relapse, in the second to third week after starting treatment.
According to the researchers, their work has not changed the findings of the original review and further updates should not be needed. "Any new studies would not change the current outcomes," said lead researcher Terry Klassen, Director of Research, Manitoba Institute of Child Health, the research division of the Children's Hospital Foundation of Manitoba.
"However, it is up to clinicians to assess whether it is worth exposing children to a longer course for the sake of a slightly reduced risk of failure in the short term," said Klassen. "Shorter courses can be safely used and generally produce fewer side effects. It is more difficult to support longer term use of antibiotics on the basis of their cost and especially considering concerns over the effects of indiscriminate use of antibiotics on resistance."
- Antibiotic treatment for ear infections in kids provides only modest benefits, study findsTue, 16 Nov 2010, 17:35:48 EST
- Bacterial vaginosis treatments: Probiotics can increase effectiveness of some antibiotic therapiesWed, 8 Jul 2009, 6:16:54 EDT
- Rutgers researchers identify new antibiotic target and new antibiotic mechanismThu, 16 Oct 2008, 13:43:31 EDT
- Short antibiotic courses safer for breathing-tube infections in childrenThu, 5 May 2011, 15:35:05 EDT
- Recommendations for treatment of inherited lung disease are unjustifiedTue, 6 Jul 2010, 20:07:37 EDT
- Antibiotics: Longer treatment times that benefit children may cost societyfrom Science CentricWed, 8 Sep 2010, 6:56:16 EDT
- Antibiotics: Longer treatment times that benefit children may cost societyfrom PhysorgWed, 8 Sep 2010, 4:21:55 EDT
- Antibiotics: Longer treatment times that benefit children may cost society, review findsfrom Science DailyTue, 7 Sep 2010, 22:21:29 EDT
Latest Science NewsletterGet the latest and most popular science news articles of the week in your Inbox! It's free!
Learn more about
Check out our next project, Biology.Net
From other science news sites
Popular science news articles
- 2 miniature spider species discovered in Giant Panda Sanctuaries of China
- Researchers reveal model of Sun's magnetic field
- The Norway spruce genome sequenced
- UCLA life scientists present new insights on climate change and species interactions
- Bacterial spare parts filter antibiotic residue from groundwater
- Allosaurus fed more like a falcon than a crocodile, new study finds
- Invasive crazy ants are displacing fire ants in areas throughout southeastern US
- Beautiful 'flowers' self-assemble in a beaker
- Scientific insurgents say 'Journal Impact Factors' distort science
- GPS solution provides 3-minute tsunami alerts