Moral judgments can be altered
MIT neuroscientists have shown they can influence people's moral judgments by disrupting a specific brain region — a finding that helps reveal how the brain constructs morality. To make moral judgments about other people, we often need to infer their intentions — an ability known as "theory of mind." For example, if a hunter shoots his friend while on a hunting trip, we need to know what the hunter was thinking: Was he secretly jealous, or did he mistake his friend for a duck?
Previous studies have shown that a brain region known as the right temporo-parietal junction (TPJ) is highly active when we think about other people's intentions, thoughts and beliefs. In the new study, the researchers disrupted activity in the right TPJ by inducing a current in the brain using a magnetic field applied to the scalp. They found that the subjects' ability to make moral judgments that require an understanding of other people's intentions — for example, a failed murder attempt — was impaired.
The researchers, led by Rebecca Saxe, MIT assistant professor of brain and cognitive sciences, report their findings in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences the week of March 29.
The study offers "striking evidence" that the right TPJ, located at the brain's surface above and behind the right ear, is critical for making moral judgments, says Liane Young, lead author of the paper. It's also startling, since under normal circumstances people are very confident and consistent in these kinds of moral judgments, says Young, a postdoctoral associate in MIT's Department of Brain and Cognitive Sciences.
"You think of morality as being a really high-level behavior," she says. "To be able to apply (a magnetic field) to a specific brain region and change people's moral judgments is really astonishing."
How they did it: The researchers used a non-invasive technique known as transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) to selectively interfere with brain activity in the right TPJ. A magnetic field applied to a small area of the skull creates weak electric currents that impede nearby brain cells' ability to fire normally, but the effect is only temporary.
In one experiment, volunteers were exposed to TMS for 25 minutes before taking a test in which they read a series of scenarios and made moral judgments of characters' actions on a scale of 1 (absolutely forbidden) to 7 (absolutely permissible).
In a second experiment, TMS was applied in 500-milisecond bursts at the moment when the subject was asked to make a moral judgment. For example, subjects were asked to judge how permissible it is for someone to let his girlfriend walk across a bridge he knows to be unsafe, even if she ends up making it across safely. In such cases, a judgment based solely on the outcome would hold the perpetrator morally blameless, even though it appears he intended to do harm.
In both experiments, the researchers found that when the right TPJ was disrupted, subjects were more likely to judge failed attempts to harm as morally permissible. Therefore, the researchers believe that TMS interfered with subjects' ability to interpret others' intentions, forcing them to rely more on outcome information to make their judgments.
Next steps: Young is now doing a study on the role of the right TPJ in judgments of people who are morally lucky or unlucky. For example, a drunk driver who hits and kills a pedestrian is unlucky, compared to an equally drunk driver who makes it home safely, but the unlucky homicidal driver tends to be judged more morally blameworthy.
- Cleanliness can compromise moral judgmentMon, 1 Dec 2008, 10:32:01 EST
- Major moral decisions use general-purpose brain circuits to manage uncertaintyWed, 25 Aug 2010, 12:37:12 EDT
- Who shalt not kill? Brain power leads to level-headedness when faced with moral dilemmasMon, 9 Jun 2008, 12:21:53 EDT
- Impaired judgment of harmful intent is linked with damage to prefrontal cortexWed, 24 Mar 2010, 15:08:43 EDT
- Changes in brain circuitry play role in moral sensitivity as people grow upFri, 27 May 2011, 16:34:40 EDT
- Study: Magnetic Waves Alter Moral Compassfrom CBSNews - ScienceTue, 30 Mar 2010, 14:21:16 EDT
- A Magnetic Field Applied to the Brain Can Alter People's Sense of Moralityfrom PopSciTue, 30 Mar 2010, 14:07:21 EDT
- Magnets can modify our morality, scientists discoverfrom BBC News: Science & NatureTue, 30 Mar 2010, 8:21:20 EDT
- Moral judgments can be alteredfrom MIT ResearchTue, 30 Mar 2010, 4:14:11 EDT
- Moral judgments can be altered: Neuroscientists influence people’s moral judgments by disrupting specific brain regionfrom Science DailyMon, 29 Mar 2010, 23:21:34 EDT
- Brain Stimulation Can Alter Our Moral Judgments, Study Suggestsfrom Scientific BloggingMon, 29 Mar 2010, 17:21:30 EDT
- Moral judgments can be altered by disrupting specific brain regionfrom PhysorgMon, 29 Mar 2010, 15:22:25 EDT
- Morality Altered by Brain Stimulationfrom Live ScienceMon, 29 Mar 2010, 15:21:58 EDT
Latest Science NewsletterGet the latest and most popular science news articles of the week in your Inbox! It's free!
Learn more about
Check out our next project, Biology.Net
From other science news sites
Popular science news articles
- Detection of the cosmic gamma ray horizon: Measures all the light in the universe since the Big Bang
- Facial-recognition technology proves its mettle
- New filtration material could make petroleum refining cheaper, more efficient
- Heart healthy lifestyle may cut kidney disease patients' risk of kidney failure
- How do cold ions slide