JAMA Viewpoint: Emerging Zika pandemic requires more WHO action now
The World Health Organization's Director-General should convene "urgently" a meeting of International Health Regulations' Emergency Committee to advise on the emerging Zika pandemic and galvanize global action, say two Georgetown University professors. In their JAMA Viewpoint published online Jan. 27, Daniel Lucey, MD, MPH, and Lawrence O. Gostin, JD, of the O'Neill Institute for National and Global Health Law at Georgetown, explain that the WHO's failure to act decisively early on in the Ebola crises likely cost thousands of lives, and they warn of potentially serious ramifications if more action isn't taken immediately with Zika.
Until recently, the Zika virus was regarded as a mild disease, but the emergence of a possible link to Guillain-Barré syndrome and neurologic birth defects (microcephaly), seen in some affected countries, has elevated concern. Recent modeling of the disease's spread "anticipates significant international spread by travelers from Brazil to the rest of the Americas, Europe, and Asia," Lucey and Gostin write.
"The critical lesson learned from the WHO's handling of the Ebola crises was the need for early and decisive action," says Gostin. "Yet WHO, and even advanced countries like the United States, were caught off guard. It would be unconscionable if a lack of preparedness resulted in hundreds of unnecessary cases of Zika and potential congenital abnormalities in newborns."
Lucey and Gostin write, "An Emergency Committee should be convened urgently to advise the Director-General about the conditions necessary to declare a Public Health Emergency of International Concern (PHEIC).The very process of convening the committee would catalyze international attention, funding, and research. While Brazil, [the Pan American Health Organization], and the [Centers for Disease Control and Prevention] have acted rapidly, WHO headquarters has thus far not been sufficiently proactive given potentially serious ramifications."
Convening the committee "does not mean that the Director-General should declare a PHEIC," and they point to the example of MERS where the WHO Emergency Committee met 10 times yet advised against declaring a PHEIC, while still offering guidance to Member states.
Additional recommendations outlined by Lucey and Gostin include mosquito control (removing water sources where breeding occurs, use of insecticide, etc.), health information campaigns, country-issued travel advisories, accelerated research and development of vaccines and declarations of public health.
"The international community cannot afford to wait for WHO to act," they conclude.
Lucey, is an infectious disease specialist and a Senior Scholar at the O'Neill Institute, and adjunct professor of medicine at Georgetown University School of Medicine.
Gostin is faculty director of the O'Neill Institute. He served on the National Academy of Medicine's Commission on a Global Health Risk Framework for the Future whose report earlier this month warned of health system deficiencies specifically in managing a pandemic disease crisis.
Source: O'Neill Institute for National and Global Health Law
Articles on the same topic
- Researchers present inner workings of Ebola vaccine trialFri, 12 Feb 2016, 15:34:39 UTC
- Eye abnormalities in infants with microcephaly associated with Zika virusTue, 9 Feb 2016, 19:12:39 UTC
- Zika virus: 5 things to knowMon, 8 Feb 2016, 18:22:03 UTC
- Umea University researchers help Europe fight spread of Zika virusMon, 8 Feb 2016, 16:54:50 UTC
- Clip-on device offers protection against mosquitoes that transmit ZikaWed, 3 Feb 2016, 17:32:36 UTC
- Researcher warns US could see substantial impact of Zika virusMon, 1 Feb 2016, 22:48:16 UTC
- UW-Madison researchers find Zika virus in Colombia, look for ways to stop itWed, 27 Jan 2016, 1:02:00 UTC
Other sources
- Scientists Scramble To Develop Tools, Treatments For Zika Virusfrom C&ENSat, 13 Feb 2016, 0:50:24 UTC
- Zika Virus Test Is ‘Weeks, Not Years’ Away, W.H.O. Saysfrom NY Times HealthSat, 13 Feb 2016, 0:20:28 UTC
- Zika Virus in Semen Provides More Evidence of Sexual Spreadfrom Live ScienceFri, 12 Feb 2016, 20:10:26 UTC
- Health minister urges Brazilians to join Zika battlefrom AP HealthFri, 12 Feb 2016, 18:30:37 UTC
- Zika virus vaccines at least 18 months away from trials, WHO saysfrom CBC: HealthFri, 12 Feb 2016, 11:40:24 UTC
- WHO: possible Zika vaccines months away from broad trialsfrom AP HealthFri, 12 Feb 2016, 9:40:32 UTC
- Obama requests $1.8 billion to fight Zika virusfrom C&ENFri, 12 Feb 2016, 3:00:52 UTC
- CDC: Strong evidence of link between Zika and microcephalyfrom UPIThu, 11 Feb 2016, 19:50:34 UTC
- Defeating Zika: The Big Questions Researchers Are Trying to Answerfrom Live ScienceThu, 11 Feb 2016, 19:01:47 UTC
- Study finds Zika virus in fetal brain, a clue in outbreakfrom AP HealthWed, 10 Feb 2016, 23:00:46 UTC
- Researchers find new Zika clues to birth defect in fetus studyfrom Reuters:ScienceWed, 10 Feb 2016, 22:50:25 UTC
- Zika virus found in fetal brainfrom LA Times - ScienceWed, 10 Feb 2016, 22:30:30 UTC
- Zika virus spreads to China, first case confirmedfrom UPIWed, 10 Feb 2016, 13:07:41 UTC
- Study in Brazil Links Zika Virus to Eye Damage in Babiesfrom NY Times HealthWed, 10 Feb 2016, 12:30:41 UTC
- China reports 1st case of imported Zika virusfrom AP HealthWed, 10 Feb 2016, 5:00:47 UTC
- China reports 1st case of imported Zika virusfrom AP HealthWed, 10 Feb 2016, 4:30:49 UTC
- Zika Vaccines Are in the Works, But Still Years Awayfrom Live ScienceWed, 10 Feb 2016, 0:23:35 UTC
- Eye abnormalities in infants with microcephaly associated with Zika virusfrom Science DailyWed, 10 Feb 2016, 0:13:29 UTC
- Zika virus linked to 'vision-threatening lesions' in babies with birth defectfrom CBC: HealthTue, 9 Feb 2016, 20:21:56 UTC
- Living with people they bite, Zika mosquitoes hard to fightfrom AP ScienceTue, 9 Feb 2016, 3:50:42 UTC
- Scientists Investigate How Viruses Like Zika Cause Birth Defectsfrom NY Times HealthTue, 9 Feb 2016, 2:00:40 UTC
- Zika Virus News: Complete Coverage of the 2016 Outbreakfrom Live ScienceMon, 8 Feb 2016, 22:05:11 UTC
- Video: Zika, mosquitoes and how to not get bittenfrom PhysorgMon, 8 Feb 2016, 22:04:43 UTC
- 5 Things to Know About Zika Virusfrom Live ScienceMon, 8 Feb 2016, 21:36:23 UTC
- Zika virus: 5 things to knowfrom Biology News NetMon, 8 Feb 2016, 21:35:56 UTC
- Living with people they bite, Zika mosquitoes hard to fightfrom AP ScienceMon, 8 Feb 2016, 19:13:17 UTC
- How a Medical Mystery in Brazil Led Doctors to Zikafrom NY Times ScienceSun, 7 Feb 2016, 23:50:42 UTC
- Brazil celebrating Carnival in full force despite Zika virus threatfrom UPISun, 7 Feb 2016, 18:50:43 UTC
- Aggressive and Human-Loving, Aedes Aegypti Mosquito Spreading Zika and Other Diseasesfrom Science BlogSat, 6 Feb 2016, 14:31:04 UTC
- CDC issues guidelines to prevent spread of Zika virus through sexual contactfrom UPISat, 6 Feb 2016, 0:41:30 UTC
- Brazilian health institute says discovered Zika in saliva, urinefrom CBC: HealthFri, 5 Feb 2016, 15:20:38 UTC
- After criticism, Brazil transferring Zika samples to USfrom AP HealthFri, 5 Feb 2016, 12:01:31 UTC
- Zika virus: Tonga concerned about possible outbreakfrom CBC: HealthFri, 5 Feb 2016, 10:50:38 UTC
- Florida readies for a fight with Zika virusfrom AP HealthFri, 5 Feb 2016, 10:30:44 UTC
- Exceptionally hot and dry winter in northeast Brazil may be linked to outbreak of the zika virusfrom Science DailyFri, 5 Feb 2016, 2:51:30 UTC
- [In Depth] The race for a Zika vaccine is onfrom Science NOWThu, 4 Feb 2016, 22:01:28 UTC
- Zika spotlights rare birth defect with a variety of causesfrom AP HealthThu, 4 Feb 2016, 20:01:36 UTC
- Zika spotlights rare birth defect with a variety of causesfrom AP HealthThu, 4 Feb 2016, 19:13:35 UTC
- Latin America scrambles to squash Zika-spreading mosquitofrom AP HealthThu, 4 Feb 2016, 18:14:45 UTC
- 5 Questions Everyone Still Has About Zika Virusfrom MSNBC: ScienceThu, 4 Feb 2016, 15:54:33 UTC
- Zika virus: Precious samples sought from Brazil by U.S., Europefrom CBC: Technology & ScienceThu, 4 Feb 2016, 15:43:44 UTC
- Florida declares health emergency for Zika virus in four countiesfrom UPIThu, 4 Feb 2016, 12:31:28 UTC
- Health officials want more Zika samples, data from Brazilfrom AP HealthThu, 4 Feb 2016, 5:40:36 UTC
- Health officials want more Zika samples, data from Brazilfrom AP ScienceThu, 4 Feb 2016, 5:34:55 UTC
- Health officials want more Zika samples, data from Brazilfrom AP HealthThu, 4 Feb 2016, 5:10:39 UTC
- US Zika case sparks questions about sex and mosquito germsfrom AP HealthWed, 3 Feb 2016, 22:51:03 UTC
- APNewsbreak: Few Zika samples being shared by Brazilfrom AP HealthWed, 3 Feb 2016, 22:21:01 UTC
- Mosquito Expert on Zika Virus: 'I Am Confident We Will See Transmission This Summer'from Newswise - ScinewsWed, 3 Feb 2016, 21:11:10 UTC
- The Latest: Health ministers probing microcephaly in Brazilfrom AP HealthWed, 3 Feb 2016, 19:10:43 UTC
- 5 Questions Everyone Still Has About Zika Virusfrom MSNBC: ScienceWed, 3 Feb 2016, 17:54:47 UTC
- Reported Cases of Zika Virus Worldwide (Infographic)from Live ScienceWed, 3 Feb 2016, 17:00:11 UTC
- Microcephaly Linked to Zika Virus Is a 'Public Health Emergency,' Officials Sayfrom Live ScienceWed, 3 Feb 2016, 16:51:10 UTC
- How Zika Virus Spreads: Chain of Events Explainedfrom Live ScienceWed, 3 Feb 2016, 16:47:52 UTC
- Sexually Transmitted Zika Case Confirmed in Texasfrom Live ScienceWed, 3 Feb 2016, 16:44:27 UTC
- Zika Prevention: The Buzz on Genetically Modified Mosquitoesfrom Live ScienceWed, 3 Feb 2016, 16:44:02 UTC
- The Latest: Ireland reports first cases of Zika virusfrom AP HealthWed, 3 Feb 2016, 14:31:05 UTC
- French Caribbean facing Zika epidemic, taking extra measuresfrom AP HealthWed, 3 Feb 2016, 14:01:31 UTC
- WHO concerned by report of sexual transmission of Zika virusfrom CBC: HealthWed, 3 Feb 2016, 11:49:57 UTC
- Higher temperatures make Zika mosquito spread disease morefrom AP HealthWed, 3 Feb 2016, 11:31:07 UTC
- Higher temperatures make Zika mosquito spread disease morefrom AP ScienceWed, 3 Feb 2016, 11:30:42 UTC
- Sexually-transmitted Zika case confirmed in Texasfrom AP HealthWed, 3 Feb 2016, 8:08:31 UTC
- U.S. Case of Zika Infection Transmitted by Sex Reported in Texasfrom NY Times HealthWed, 3 Feb 2016, 4:20:39 UTC
- Clip-on device offers protection against mosquitoes that transmit Zikafrom Science DailyWed, 3 Feb 2016, 3:21:32 UTC
- First U.S. cases of Zika virus reported in Texas; Officials cite sexual transmissionfrom UPIWed, 3 Feb 2016, 0:21:07 UTC
- Sexually-transmitted Zika case confirmed in Texasfrom AP HealthTue, 2 Feb 2016, 22:50:39 UTC
- First Case of U.S. Transmission in Ongoing Zika Outbreak Announced in Texasfrom Scientific AmericanTue, 2 Feb 2016, 21:54:09 UTC
- Sexually transmitted Zika case confirmed in Texasfrom CBC: HealthTue, 2 Feb 2016, 21:03:27 UTC
- Birth defect link to Zika 'guilty until proven innocent:' WHOfrom CBC: HealthTue, 2 Feb 2016, 15:02:45 UTC
- What we know: WHO declares global emergency over Zika virusfrom AP HealthMon, 1 Feb 2016, 22:15:40 UTC
- WHO declares Zika outbreak a global emergency; CDC says pregnant women at greatest riskfrom UPIMon, 1 Feb 2016, 19:41:57 UTC
- W.H.O. to Decide on Response to Zika Virusfrom NY Times HealthMon, 1 Feb 2016, 17:26:22 UTC
- Zika virus concerns weighed by WHO expertsfrom CBC: HealthMon, 1 Feb 2016, 16:11:21 UTC
- WHO's Zika response must strike a delicate balance: doctorfrom CBC: HealthSun, 31 Jan 2016, 23:00:44 UTC
- CBC Forum: How do we stop the spread of the Zika virus?from CBC: HealthSun, 31 Jan 2016, 16:41:05 UTC
- Vaccine for Zika Virus May Be Years Away, Disease Experts Warnfrom NY Times HealthSun, 31 Jan 2016, 8:42:03 UTC
- Tears and Bewilderment in Brazilian City Facing Zika Crisisfrom NY Times HealthSun, 31 Jan 2016, 8:41:21 UTC
- New Weapon to Fight Zika: The Mosquitofrom NY Times HealthSun, 31 Jan 2016, 8:40:39 UTC
- Zika virus has infected 2,100 pregnant Colombians, health officials sayfrom CBC: HealthSat, 30 Jan 2016, 23:41:08 UTC
- What Canadian travellers need to know about the Zika virusfrom CBC: HealthSat, 30 Jan 2016, 10:40:45 UTC
- Asian countries urge sick travelers to report Zika symptomsfrom AP HealthSat, 30 Jan 2016, 4:10:39 UTC
- Researchers Weigh Risks of Zika Spreading at Rio Olympicsfrom NY Times HealthSat, 30 Jan 2016, 2:33:57 UTC
- New York City Officials Announce Efforts to Fight Zika Virusfrom NY Times HealthSat, 30 Jan 2016, 2:33:32 UTC
- Canadian mosquito spread of Zika untestedfrom CBC: HealthSat, 30 Jan 2016, 1:50:41 UTC
- Colombia, Venezuela report Zika links to Guillain-Barre syndromefrom CBC: HealthFri, 29 Jan 2016, 23:10:44 UTC
- 4 confirmed Zika cases among Canadian travellersfrom CBC: HealthFri, 29 Jan 2016, 19:12:22 UTC
- Photos of the Desperate Effort to Control Zika Virusfrom National GeographicFri, 29 Jan 2016, 18:14:34 UTC
- VIDEO: WHO warns Zika could infect millionsfrom BBC News: Science & NatureFri, 29 Jan 2016, 16:47:00 UTC
- Uganda: Little concern, impact of Zika virus in Zika Forestfrom AP HealthFri, 29 Jan 2016, 14:57:39 UTC
- Zika virus: Canadian-U.S. vaccine could be ready by year's endfrom CBC: HealthFri, 29 Jan 2016, 14:21:29 UTC
- Zika Virus FAQs: Top Questions Answeredfrom Live ScienceThu, 28 Jan 2016, 22:51:38 UTC
- Why Zika Is This Year’s Scary Virusfrom National GeographicThu, 28 Jan 2016, 22:01:32 UTC
- Canadian Blood Services to defer donations from travellers to Zika areasfrom CBC: HealthThu, 28 Jan 2016, 19:21:22 UTC
- Limited Zika Virus Outbreaks 'Likely' in USfrom Live ScienceThu, 28 Jan 2016, 19:09:47 UTC
- Zika Virus - What You Need To Know | Videofrom Live ScienceThu, 28 Jan 2016, 17:15:34 UTC
- WHO raises concern about 'explosivley' spreading Zika virusfrom UPIThu, 28 Jan 2016, 16:08:23 UTC
- Zika Virus ‘Spreading Explosively’ in Americas, W.H.O. Saysfrom NY Times ScienceThu, 28 Jan 2016, 15:30:38 UTC
- Health official doubts Zika virus poses major threat to USfrom AP HealthThu, 28 Jan 2016, 13:09:48 UTC
- WHO chief calls for emergency meeting on Zika virusfrom CBC: HealthThu, 28 Jan 2016, 13:07:57 UTC
- UN to decide if Zika virus is a global health emergencyfrom AP HealthThu, 28 Jan 2016, 12:36:52 UTC
- 'Growing Zika crisis' in Brazilian cityfrom BBC News: Science & NatureThu, 28 Jan 2016, 12:36:27 UTC
- Brazil hopes to tackle Zika with GM mosquitosfrom SciDevThu, 28 Jan 2016, 11:31:03 UTC
- 3 known recent cases of Canadians who contracted Zika abroad, health officials sayfrom CBC: HealthThu, 28 Jan 2016, 6:14:22 UTC
- Zika Virus: Symptoms, Risk, Treatment & Preventionfrom Live ScienceThu, 28 Jan 2016, 0:51:03 UTC
- Health Leaders Home In On Zikafrom C&ENWed, 27 Jan 2016, 23:00:45 UTC
- Zika virus infects Danish touristfrom CBC: HealthWed, 27 Jan 2016, 17:02:00 UTC
- Venezuela doctors worried about official silence on Zikafrom AP HealthWed, 27 Jan 2016, 14:57:17 UTC
- Discovered in Uganda, Zika there not considered a threatfrom AP HealthWed, 27 Jan 2016, 12:54:25 UTC
- Brazil Will Deploy Troops to Spread Awareness of Zika Virusfrom NY Times HealthWed, 27 Jan 2016, 12:50:59 UTC
- Danish hospital says case of Zika virus discoveredfrom AP HealthWed, 27 Jan 2016, 8:01:33 UTC
- As Zika Virus Rises, Vaccine Development Gets Attentionfrom Live ScienceWed, 27 Jan 2016, 1:00:40 UTC
- The Latest: US again expands travel alert to pregnant womenfrom AP HealthTue, 26 Jan 2016, 22:47:19 UTC
- Zika Virus found in Colombia: Looking for ways to stop itfrom Science DailyTue, 26 Jan 2016, 22:41:02 UTC
- Zika virus 'a game-changer' for mosquito-borne diseasesfrom Science DailyTue, 26 Jan 2016, 20:00:37 UTC
- Brazil deploying 220,000 soldiers in awareness fight against Zika virusfrom UPITue, 26 Jan 2016, 18:04:26 UTC
- The Latest: 18 confirmed cases of Zika in Puerto Ricofrom AP HealthTue, 26 Jan 2016, 17:40:31 UTC
- UN: Zika virus link to small-head condition 'circumstantial'from AP HealthTue, 26 Jan 2016, 14:03:44 UTC
- El Salvador’s Advice on Zika: Don’t Have Babiesfrom NY Times HealthTue, 26 Jan 2016, 13:41:01 UTC
- Two Cases Suggest Zika Virus Could Be Spread Through Sexfrom NY Times ScienceMon, 25 Jan 2016, 23:55:13 UTC
- What to know about the tropical Zika virus in Latin Americafrom AP HealthMon, 25 Jan 2016, 21:31:26 UTC
- Zika virus: what you need to knowfrom CBC: HealthMon, 25 Jan 2016, 19:51:29 UTC
- Zika outbreak likely to reach across Americas: WHOfrom CBC: HealthMon, 25 Jan 2016, 14:31:10 UTC
- Zika virus 'to spread across Americas'from BBC News: Science & NatureMon, 25 Jan 2016, 13:02:54 UTC
- U.K. diagnoses 3 with Zika virus; CDC expands travel warningsfrom UPISun, 24 Jan 2016, 15:40:41 UTC
- El Salvador Advises Against Pregnancy Until 2018 in Answer to Zika Fearsfrom NY Times HealthSun, 24 Jan 2016, 3:50:36 UTC
- Mosquito-Borne Zika Virus Found in 3 New York State Patientsfrom NY Times HealthSat, 23 Jan 2016, 5:22:56 UTC
- C.D.C. Issues Travel Alert for 8 More Locations Over Zika Virusfrom NY Times HealthSat, 23 Jan 2016, 5:22:31 UTC
- Health officials probe tie between Zika, paralyzing syndromefrom AP HealthFri, 22 Jan 2016, 22:41:05 UTC
- Zika virus travel alert adds 8 placesfrom CBC: HealthFri, 22 Jan 2016, 22:30:37 UTC
- US Virgin Islands reports its first Zika virus casefrom AP HealthFri, 22 Jan 2016, 17:42:47 UTC
- Zika Virus May be Linked to Surge in Rare Syndrome in Brazilfrom NY Times HealthThu, 21 Jan 2016, 23:10:35 UTC
- Cornell Biologist Available for Interviews About the Zika Virus Following Outbreak in Latin Americafrom Newswise - ScinewsThu, 21 Jan 2016, 19:00:25 UTC
- Update: Spread of Zika Virus Prompts Travel Advisoriesfrom NY Times HealthThu, 21 Jan 2016, 6:21:08 UTC
- More pregnant women in U.S. diagnosed with Zika virusfrom UPIWed, 20 Jan 2016, 22:01:27 UTC
- "Babymoon" Turns into Zika Nightmarefrom Scientific AmericanWed, 20 Jan 2016, 19:55:52 UTC
- More birth defects linked to Zika virus in Brazilfrom CBC: HealthWed, 20 Jan 2016, 19:43:27 UTC
- Baby Moon Turns Into Zika Nightmarefrom Scientific AmericanWed, 20 Jan 2016, 18:55:26 UTC
- C.D.C. Urges Zika Testing for Some Who Are Pregnantfrom NY Times HealthWed, 20 Jan 2016, 12:50:58 UTC
- Q&A: Hawaii baby born with defect linked to Zika virusfrom AP ScienceWed, 20 Jan 2016, 10:10:35 UTC
- Q&A: Hawaii baby born with defect linked to Zika virusfrom AP HealthWed, 20 Jan 2016, 10:02:10 UTC
- Q&A: Hawaii baby born with defect linked to Zika virusfrom AP HealthTue, 19 Jan 2016, 23:51:13 UTC
- Q&A: Hawaii baby born with defect linked to Zika virusfrom AP ScienceTue, 19 Jan 2016, 23:30:36 UTC
- Ask pregnant women about travel to areas with Zika virus, CDC advises doctorsfrom CBC: HealthTue, 19 Jan 2016, 22:21:03 UTC
- Some Pregnant Women in US Should Be Tested for Zika Virus: CDCfrom Live ScienceTue, 19 Jan 2016, 22:11:03 UTC
- CDC: Ask pregnant women about trips to Zika outbreak areasfrom AP HealthTue, 19 Jan 2016, 21:29:37 UTC
- Jamaica advises women to delay pregnancy due to Zika virusfrom AP HealthMon, 18 Jan 2016, 18:21:28 UTC
- Pregnant women should consult doctors on travel: Brazil's health ministryfrom CBC: HealthMon, 18 Jan 2016, 15:01:02 UTC
- Zika Warning Spotlights Latin America’s Fight Against Mosquito-Borne Diseasesfrom NY Times ScienceMon, 18 Jan 2016, 3:32:40 UTC
- To Protect Against Zika Virus, Pregnant Women Are Warned About Latin American Tripsfrom NY Times ScienceSat, 16 Jan 2016, 19:50:58 UTC
- U.S. Says Pregnant Women Should Stay Clear of Zikafrom Scientific AmericanSat, 16 Jan 2016, 1:50:58 UTC
- Pregnant women in U.S. advised against travel to Zika-hit countriesfrom CBC: HealthSat, 16 Jan 2016, 1:50:33 UTC
- C.D.C. Calls Off Advisory for Women Related to Zika Virusfrom NY Times HealthSat, 16 Jan 2016, 1:41:01 UTC
- Pregnant women told to avoid countries with Zika outbreaksfrom AP HealthSat, 16 Jan 2016, 0:30:33 UTC