Do spending cuts cost lives?
Radical cuts to social welfare spending to reduce budget deficits could cause not just economic pain but cost lives, warn experts in a study published on bmj.com today. While there is a major debate under way about the potential economic impacts of radical budget cuts in Europe, David Stuckler from the University of Oxford and his colleagues dissect the effect of public spending on people's health.
Their analysis shows that levels of social spending in Europe are "strongly associated" with risks of death, especially from diseases relating to social circumstances, such as heart attacks and alcohol-induced illness.
As such, they argue that, although governments may feel they are protecting health by safeguarding healthcare budgets, social welfare spending is as important, if not moreso, for population health.
The team evaluated data on social welfare spending collected by the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) from 15 European countries in the years 1980 to 2005. This includes programmes to provide support to families and children, help the unemployed obtain jobs, and support for people with disabilities, all of which could plausibly affect health.
They analysed the relationship between trends in these data and social spending. They found that when social spending was high, mortality rates fell, but when they were low, mortality rates rose substantially.
Based on their mathematical models, the researchers estimated that each £70 reduction in social welfare spending per person would increase alcohol-related deaths by about 2.8% and cardiovascular mortality by 1.2%, so that even modest budget cuts could have a significant impact on public health.
The researchers found spending on social welfare to promote health, and not simply healthcare, had the greatest impact on public health. However, they also found that reducing spending on non-welfare sources, such as military or prisons, had no such negative impact on the public's health.
"This result indicates that some aspects of population health are sensitive to spending on social support," say the authors. "Nevertheless, health and social welfare programmes appears to be a key determinant of future population health that should be taken into account in ongoing economic debates."
They add: "This report reveals that ordinary people may be paying the ultimate price for budget cuts - potentially costing them their lives. If we want to promote a sustainable recovery in Britain, we must first ensure that we have taken care of people's most basic health needs."
Source: BMJ-British Medical Journal
- Study shows health care spending spurs economic growthMon, 14 Dec 2009, 16:44:02 EST
- Consortium warns against clear-cutting selected science budgetsTue, 12 Jul 2011, 17:04:33 EDT
- Are we spending too much on health?Fri, 26 Sep 2008, 3:57:51 EDT
- Population health plays a bigger role in geographic differences in Medicare spendingWed, 12 May 2010, 19:22:15 EDT
- Report reveals economic, social costs of hunger in AmericaWed, 5 Oct 2011, 23:37:37 EDT
- Study finds welfare cuts can cost livesfrom Reuters:ScienceSun, 27 Jun 2010, 10:14:37 EDT
- Study finds welfare cuts can cost livesfrom Reuters:ScienceSun, 27 Jun 2010, 6:21:18 EDT
- Study finds welfare cuts can cost livesfrom Reuters:ScienceSat, 26 Jun 2010, 18:00:24 EDT
- Study finds welfare cuts can cost livesfrom Reuters:ScienceSat, 26 Jun 2010, 13:35:22 EDT
- Study finds welfare cuts can cost livesfrom Reuters:ScienceSat, 26 Jun 2010, 11:56:22 EDT
- Do spending cuts cost lives?from Science CentricFri, 25 Jun 2010, 7:21:32 EDT
- Do spending cuts cost lives?from PhysorgThu, 24 Jun 2010, 21:00:12 EDT
- Study finds welfare cuts can cost livesfrom Reuters:ScienceThu, 24 Jun 2010, 19:30:15 EDT
Latest Science NewsletterGet the latest and most popular science news articles of the week in your Inbox! It's free!
Learn more about
Check out our next project, Biology.Net
From other science news sites
Popular science news articles
- Which qubit my dear? New method to distinguish between neighbouring quantum bits
- Chemical probe confirms that body makes its own rotten egg gas, H2S, to benefit health
- IQ link to baby's weight gain in first month
- Exposure to high pollution levels during pregnancy may increase risk of having child with autism
- Pioneering breakthrough of chemical nanoengineering to design drugs controlled by light
- Even with defects, graphene is strongest material in the world
- Detection of the cosmic gamma ray horizon: Measures all the light in the universe since the Big Bang
- Genetic engineering alters mosquitoes' sense of smell
- Allosaurus fed more like a falcon than a crocodile, new study finds
- 'Popcorn' particle pathways promise better lithium-ion batteries